Title: Beyond Snowden
Author: Timothy H. Edgar
Edgar, Timothy H. (2017). Beyond Snowden: Privacy, Mass Surveillance, and the Struggle to Reform the NSA. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press
Date Posted: May 4, 2017
America’s mass surveillance programs, once secret, can no longer be ignored. While Edward Snowden began the process in 2013 with his leaks of top secret documents, the Obama administration’s own reforms have also helped bring NSA and its programs of signals intelligence collection out of the shadows. The real question is: What should we do about mass surveillance?
Edgar, a long-time civil liberties activist who worked inside the Intelligence Community for six years during the Bush and Obama administrations, believes that the NSA’s programs are a profound threat to the privacy of everyone in the world. At the same time, he argues that mass surveillance programs can be made consistent with democratic values, if we make the hard choices needed to bring transparency, accountability, privacy, and human rights protections into complex programs of intelligence collection. Although the NSA and other agencies already comply with rules intended to prevent them from spying on Americans, Edgar argues that the rules—most of which date from the 1970s—are inadequate for this century. Reforms adopted during the Obama administration are a good first step but, in his view, do not go nearly far enough.
Edgar argues that our communications today—and the national security threats we face—are both global and digital. In the twenty-first century, the only way to protect our privacy as Americans is to do a better job of protecting everyone’s privacy. Edgar explains both why and how we can do this, without sacrificing the vital intelligence capabilities we need to keep ourselves and our allies safe. If we do, we set a positive example for other nations that must confront challenges like terrorism while preserving human rights. The United States already leads the world in mass surveillance. It can lead the world in mass surveillance reform.